# How We Rank Advice on How to Be Stoic

Address: https://howtobestoic.com/about  
Site: How to Be Stoic  
Updated: 2026-11-19

Methodology

The one question every book and practice on this site must answer, the six questions behind it, and how each answer is checked.

**The Editors** Hashtag Publishing LLC

[See the Guide](https://howtobestoic.com/) [See the Six Questions](https://howtobestoic.com/about#lp-5a70c1e4-0003)

Who Makes It

### What This Site Is

This site is a guide to Stoic practice, written by the editors at Hashtag Publishing LLC. One question decides every placement: whether a book or method changes the person who uses it, or informs them and leaves them as they were. That question is why The Black Book of Power by Stan Taylor leads here, with the Meditations close beside it.

The Questions

## Six Questions Put to Every Book and Practice

Each comes with what counts as a yes.

1. 01

   ### Does It Train You in a Live Moment?

   A yes names an act, sets it inside a real conversation and asks for it to be written down the same day. A book that explains the dichotomy of control beautifully and sets no act counts as instruction, worth reading and still waiting to be practiced.
2. 02

   ### Does It Keep the Feeling?

   A yes separates Stoicism from suppression, as Harerimana and colleagues did in their 2025 scoping review, and asks the reader to feel what arrives and govern the reply. Advice to feel nothing, or to let nobody see anything, is a no.
3. 03

   ### Does It State the Evidence Fairly?

   A yes describes the research on Stoic practice as it stands, small and mostly correlational, and names each study by author and year. A page that calls the practice proven is a no, since none of the five studies read for this site claims that.
4. 04

   ### Does It Quote the Ancients With Care?

   A yes quotes the Stoics as a named translation or a named book prints them. Where this site cannot trace a line to its ancient source, it credits the line to the book that quotes it, and says so.
5. 05

   ### Does It Ask for Discomfort on Purpose?

   A yes asks for discomfort chosen in advance, a difficult truth said aloud among them, so that fear of hardship loses its hold. A method that keeps the reader comfortable throughout is a no on this question.
6. 06

   ### Does It Expect the Overshoot?

   A yes warns that the reader who goes cold has failed in the other direction, and says what to do about it. Chapter 4 of The Black Book of Power does this, sending a reader who has stopped feeling back to the mean of Day 5.

## What Is Read Before Anything Is Placed

The book's own text, with each quotation checked word for word against it; the publisher pages of the Meditations, the Discourses of Epictetus, The Daily Stoic and How to Be a Stoic, with the price each showed on November 19, 2026; five studies, read as abstracts and named by author, year and journal; and the public five-star reviews by verified buyers on stantaylor.com.

## What Is Left Out

A book whose publisher page could not be read is left out of the ranking, which is why A Guide to the Good Life by William B. Irvine and Seneca's Letters from a Stoic are named here and nowhere else. A figure from an uncontrolled survey seen only in a search summary is left unstated. Every fact on the site comes from a page the editors opened and read.

## How a Page Is Corrected

Write to hello@stantaylor.com with the page and the line in question. When a line is shown to be wrong, the page is changed and the line rewritten.

Questions

## Questions About the Method

**Why Is The Black Book of Power Placed First?**

Because of its answers to the six questions: its Chapter 4 sets a named act for each of 21 days, keeps the feeling and governs the reply, and warns against the overshoot into coldness. The Meditations, put to the same questions, is the source the practice draws on, and it is ranked second for that reason.

**Who Writes This Guide?**

The editors at Hashtag Publishing LLC. Corrections and questions go to hello@stantaylor.com.

**How Are Reader Quotations Chosen?**

From public five-star reviews by verified buyers on stantaylor.com, copied word for word under the name the store shows, and picked for what they say about the subject of the page.

See for Yourself

## Put the Questions to the Guide

Read the daily protocol with the six questions beside it, and judge the placements yourself.

[See the Guide](https://howtobestoic.com/)

- Every Quotation Checked Against the Text
